The Value Of Carnelian In 2023 By Color (Reasonable prices!)

By Dr. Keith Jackson - Geology PhD

| Updated

The Value Of Carnelian In 2023 By Color (Reasonable prices!)

By Dr. Keith Jackson - Geology PhD


When it comes to gems that captivate with their mesmerizing hues and timeless allure, nothing compares to Carnelian. Its warm shades of colors evoke a sense of vitality and creates images of flickering flames or dawning sun.

That doesn’t mean it’s easy to tell how much a carnelian is worth or what it’s real value is. Fortunately, we can help!

Beyond its looks, Carnelian is also renowned for its significance in different cultures across ages. Ancient Egyptians say it has protective properties and people in ancient Middle East regard it as a stone of authority and nobility.

The value of this gemstone go beyond its cultural and historical significance. Its unique combination of qualities draw people from all over. Let’s dive deeper into Carnelian’s worth and understand why it continues to be treasured around the globe today.

What Carnelian Is

Carnelian is a variety of Chalcedony, which forms when silica-rich solutions slowly fill the cavities within rocks.

Over time, these solutions crystallize and solidify, giving rise to this beautiful gemstone.

What makes Carnelian special is its warm and vibrant colors. Think of the colors you see during a beautiful sunset or the changing leaves in the fall— that’s how this gem looks! It’s like looking into a tiny, magical world where the colors dance and shimmer.

Because of this, Carnelian’s color is the most important factor that affects its price. Below are the different hues of this gem and its corresponding worth:

Red Carnelian

Three vibrant Red Carnelian set as pendants on silver necklaces
Red Carnelian Pendants photo provided by and available for purchase at GemStoneAppeal

True to its name, Red Carnelian displays a rich shade of red, which is a result of iron oxide impurities present during its formation. Its value lies in its striking appearance and unique properties.

A Red Carnelian’s color radiates warmth and vitality. Its transparency allows light to penetrate and interact with its internal structure. This results in a captivating play of colors and a mesmerizing glow.

Red Carnelian’s rarity and exceptional color make it highly sought after in the gemstone market.

How much is Red Carnelian worth

Red is the most valuable color of a Carnelian, so it’s worth a bit more than the others. As of writing, its price ranges from $2 to $30 per carat.

Orange Carnelian

A bracelet made out of unpolished, raw Orange Carnelians

Exhibiting a lively shade of orange, Orange Carnelian boasts of striking appearance. Its hue evokes feelings of joy and enthusiasm, making it a sought-after gemstone for jewelry enthusiasts.

This gem’s translucency also enables light to penetrate its surface. Because of this, it reveals a delightful interplay of colors and a radiant glow. Like the red type, Orange Carnelian’s scarcity and exceptional color contribute to its value.

How much is Orange Carnelian worth

Next to Red Carnelian, an Orange Carnelian is valuable at a price of $1 to $25 per carat.

Yellow Carnelian

Necklace made out of big polished pieces of Yellow and Orange Carnelian
Yellow Carnelian Necklace photo provided by and available for purchase at SanaGem

If you’re after a specimen that displays a radiant but warm color, then a Yellow Carnelian is perfect for you. Its captivating color is due to iron oxide impurities that were present during its formation.

Beyond its looks, Yellow Carnelian is associated with confidence, abundance, and personal power. It’s meant for those seeking to enhance their inner strength and manifestation abilities. A Yellow Carnelian’s blend of aesthetic beauty and symbolic significance makes it a valuable gemstone.

How much is Yellow Carnelian worth

A Yellow Carnelian’s price ranges from $1 to $20 per carat, which is only a bit lower than that of an orange or red one.

Pink Carnelian

Bracelet made out of polished, round Pink Carnelian

With its delicate and alluring shade of pink, it’s no wonder why a Pink Carnelian is a collector’s dream. Its soft and romantic pink hue is because of manganese impurities present during its formation.

Aside from radiating charm and elegance with its color, a Pink Carnelian is also associated with emotions, love, and compassion. This makes it a favored gem if you want to enhance your emotional well-being and foster harmonious relationships.

How much is Pink Carnelian worth

The value of a Pink Carnelian is current at $1 to $20 per carat.

Brown Carnelian

A pair of earrings adorned by Brown Carnelians

While the other colors of this gem can be described as bright and cheery, there’s also the Brown Carnelian, which displays an earthy shade of brown. Its rich hue is linked to a sense of grounding and warmth.

Like the other colors of this gemstone, Brown Carnelian is believed to have metaphysical properties. It’s associated with stability, protection, and connection to the natural world. This makes it a great choice if you’re seeking grounding and balance in your life.

How much is Brown Carnelian worth

Same with its yellow and pink counterparts, a Brown Carnelian’s price goes from $1 to $20 per carat.

Blue Carnelian

Silver bracelet with Blue Carnelians

Blue Carnelian exhibits a rare and striking shade of blue. Unlike other colors that are known for their warm tones, Blue Carnelian stands out with its cool and serene coloration. Its mesmerizing blue color is the result of traces of copper or other transition metals present during its formation.

Because of its rarity and eye-catching appeal, Blue Carnelian is highly coveted. It exudes a sense of calmness and tranquility. It’s also often associated with enhancing communication, intuition, and self-expression.

How much is Blue Carnelian worth

The price of a Blue Carnelian per carat can go from $1 to $30 per carat.

Black Carnelian

A silver gold spinner ring with a polished Black Carnelian as center stone

A Black Carnelian’s distinct appearance, with its rich and deep black color, sets it apart from other Carnelian varieties. Its intense black coloration is due to iron oxide and carbonaceous materials.

Black Carnelian’s deep black color exudes a sense of mystery and elegance. This gem is said to have the ability to absorb negative energy and promote balance.

How much is Black Carnelian worth

A Black Carnelian’s price in the current market ranges from $1 to $20 per carat.

Why Carnelian Is So Expensive

Silver and gold ring with an oval Orange Carnelian

With its timeless charm and allure, Carnelian has captivated hearts and minds throughout history. But why is it so highly valued? Let’s discuss the reasons one by one.

Carnelian’s vibrant and enchanting colors play a significant role in its value. Imagine a sunset painting the sky in different colors— it’s like having a piece of that natural beauty in the palm of your hand. Its warm hues inspire feelings of vitality, passion, and warmth, and its lively colors are like a burst of energy, joy, and positivity.

Carnelian’s transparency also adds an extra layer of allure. Light dances within the gem, revealing mesmerizing patterns and flashes of radiance. That’s why jewelers and collectors love to use it to create unique and eye-catching jewelry pieces.

But Carnelian’s value extends beyond its aesthetics. It carries with it a rich tapestry of history and symbolism. Throughout ancient times, it held great significance in different cultures.

Ancient Egyptians believed it possessed protective properties, guarding against evil and enhancing courage. In the Middle East, it was considered a stone of authority and nobility. Such historical and cultural connections contribute to Carnelian’s desirability. It carries the weight of centuries of belief and tradition.

Carnelian also holds metaphysical properties that add to its value. It’s believed to enhance motivation, creativity, and vitality. Wearing one is said to ignite the spark of inspiration and awaken your inner fire. It’s also believed to promote emotional balance and protect against negative energies. This allows you to navigate life’s ups and downs with confidence and resilience.

Don’t let the confusion of carnelian with other rocks and minerals discourage you. Our guides are designed to help you confidently identify carnelian so that you can appreciate its unique characteristics:

How To Determine The Value Of Carnelian

Necklace made out of different colors of Carnelian beads
Carnelian-Beaded Necklace photo provided by and available for purchase at ElisaJewelryArt

Different factors influence and affect the value and price of Carnelian. Below are the most influential of them:


The intensity and uniformity of a Carnelian’s color play the most crucial role in determining its price. Samples with vivid and evenly distributed hues are highly valued. Intense and bright colors of Red and Orange tend to command higher prices compared to lighter or duller shades.

Size and Weight

Generally, larger Carnelian specimens command higher prices due to their rarity. But this comes second to the overall quality and color play of a sample.


The geographical origin of the Carnelian can also affect its value. Certain locations are known for producing higher-quality gemstones, which can increase their price.

Cut and Shape

The quality of a Carnelian’s cut and shape can influence its price. Well-cut and symmetrical specimens that maximize color and brilliance are more sought after. Additionally, unique and uncommon shapes may also command higher prices due to their rarity.


Carnelians with minimal inclusions or visible flaws are considered more valuable. Higher clarity enhances the gem’s transparency and overall beauty.

Carving and Craftsmanship

Carving and craftsmanship play a significant role in determining the price of a piece of Carnelian. The skill involved in transforming a raw specimen into a beautifully-carved piece can greatly enhance its value.


The presence of any treatments or enhancements, such as dyeing or heat treatments, can affect the price of Carnelian. Natural and untreated ones are generally more valuable than those with artificial enhancements.

Carnelian Price By Color

The price of Carnelian can vary based on their color, with different hues commanding different values, as we’ve discussed above. To give you a clearer picture of Carnelian’s price depending on color, refer to the table below:

Carnelian values by color

Red Carnelian$2 to $30 per carat
Orange Carnelian$1 to $25 per carat
Yellow Carnelian$1 to $20 per carat
Pink Carnelian$1 to $20 per carat
Brown Carnelian$1 to $20 per carat
Blue Carnelian$1 to $30 per carat
Black Carnelian$1 to $20 per carat

If you want sophistication with a tinge of youthful vibrance, Carnelian is your go-to gem at a reasonable price!

Now, let’s have some fun and play with the different values of Carnelian depending on different units of measurement.

Carnelian pricing by unit of measurement

A carat of Carnelian$1 to $30
A gram of Carnelian$5.00 to $150.00
An ounce of Carnelian$142 to $4,252
A kilogram of Carnelian$5,000 to $150,000
A pound of Carnelian$2,268 to $68,039
A ton of Carnelian$4,535,925 to $136,077,750

How To Get An Appraisal On Your Carnelian

Shiny round Red Carnelian beads used in a bracelet

If you want to get an appraisal on your Carnelian gemstone, there are several ways you can do so.

You can avail the services of a professional gem appraiser who is certified by a reputable organization, like the Gemological Institute of America.

They can provide a detailed appraisal report that includes information about your gem’s overall value.

You can also submit your Carnelian to a reputable gemological laboratory for analysis and appraisal. These laboratories have trained gemologists who use advanced techniques and equipment to evaluate gemstones.

If you prefer a more affordable way, you can also approach certified gemstone dealers. Make sure, though, that you choose a reputable and trusted dealer with a solid track record.

Lastly, there are various online platforms that offer gemstone appraisal services. For this, you need to submit detailed information and photographs of your Carnelian gem for evaluation.

Whichever way you choose, it’s important to provide as much information about your Carnelian. You can also get multiple appraisals from different sources to compare and ensure accuracy.

About Dr. Keith Jackson - Geology PhD

Keith Jackson is an avid rockhound who is constantly exploring new sites to expand his collection. He has worked as a professional Geologist for over 20 years and holds a PhD in Geology from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, a Masters Degree in Geology from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, and a Bachelors Degree in Geology from the University of Connecticut.

Leave a Comment