16 Most Incredible Hidden Treasures In Michigan

By Keith Jackson - Geologist

| Updated

16 Most Incredible Hidden Treasures In Michigan

By Keith Jackson - Geologist

Updated

Michigan is full of surprises, and not just the ones you see on its beautiful lakeshores or in its charming small towns. Hidden across the state are stories of lost treasures waiting to be uncovered. From buried loot to long-forgotten caches, these treasures are more than just legends—they could be worth millions.

Whether you’re combing the beaches of Lake Michigan or exploring the forests of the Upper Peninsula, the hunt brings adventure right to your backyard.

Some of these tales date back to Michigan’s early days, when fur traders and settlers roamed the land. Others involve infamous outlaws who may have left their loot behind.

Who knows? Your next weekend adventure could turn into a hunt for Michigan’s hidden fortune.

The Incredible Treasures Of Michigan That Are Waiting To Be Discovered

Take a look at some of the most extraordinary treasures still waiting to be found:

Le Griffon Shipwreck – $3,000,000+

The Le Griffon was built in 1679 by French explorer René-Robert Cavelier de La Salle. It was one of the first large ships to sail the Great Lakes, carrying furs and goods for trade.

On its maiden voyage, the ship mysteriously vanished, and its valuable cargo was lost. The ship’s final journey began on Lake Michigan, where it was loaded with a massive haul of pelts.

These furs were meant to be sold in Europe, making them incredibly valuable for La Salle’s expedition. The cargo, along with the ship itself, was hidden when the vessel disappeared, leaving only rumors of its fate.

La Salle trusted his crew to deliver the ship safely, but many believe they may have scuttled it for personal gain. Others think a storm sank the vessel near the Beaver Island area.

The treasure hidden aboard was the ship’s cargo of furs. These pelts, including beaver, otter, and other animals, were highly prized in the 17th century fur trade. Historians estimate the ship carried thousands of these valuable furs.

How much the treasure would be worth today

Experts estimate the total worth of the treasure could exceed $3 million, considering both the market value of the pelts and the ship’s historical importance.

The Lost Treasure of Fort Mackinac – $5,000,000+

Fort Mackinac, located on Mackinac Island, was a strategic military post during the 18th and 19th centuries. It was originally built by the British during the American Revolution and later controlled by both British and American forces.

During the War of 1812, a treasure of gold and silver coins is rumored to have been buried near the fort to protect it from enemy hands.

The treasure is believed to have been hidden by British soldiers during their occupation of the fort. Facing the possibility of American capture, they reportedly buried the coins in a secret location.

The exact spot has been lost to history, but treasure hunters speculate it may be somewhere on Mackinac Island, possibly near the fort or in its surrounding forests.

Fort Mackinac played a critical role in the Great Lakes region, making it a target during the war. As British forces prepared for potential defeat, they likely chose to hide their wealth rather than let it fall into enemy hands.

The hidden treasure consists of gold and silver coins, which were likely meant to fund military operations or pay soldiers. The hoard is estimated to have included thousands of coins, making it a substantial fortune for its time.

How much the treasure would be worth today

With historical gold and silver coins valued at $2,000 to $3,000 each, the entire hoard could be worth $5 million or more.

Al Capone’s Buried Loot – $10,000,000+

Al Capone, the infamous Chicago mob boss of the Prohibition era, is said to have hidden a fortune in Michigan. Known for his illegal liquor operations and criminal empire, Capone often used remote locations to stash his ill-gotten gains.

According to local legends, he buried a treasure of cash, gold, and jewelry somewhere in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.

The loot is believed to have been hidden by Capone and his associates during the 1920s or early 1930s. Some reports suggest it was buried near the town of Hermansville or in the vast forests surrounding Escanaba.

Capone frequently traveled to Michigan to avoid law enforcement and to oversee smuggling routes, making it a likely hiding spot for his treasure.

Capone’s ties to Michigan included his use of cabins and hidden campsites in the Upper Peninsula. These locations provided privacy and were ideal for hiding valuable assets.

The hidden treasure is thought to include large amounts of cash, gold coins, and valuable jewelry. It may also contain documents or artifacts connected to Capone’s criminal activities, which would be of great historical interest.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The combination of cash, gold, and jewelry could easily exceed $10 million. Its connection to Capone’s notorious legacy would likely add even more value.

Confederate Gold in Lake Michigan – $20,000,000+

The legend of Confederate gold in Lake Michigan dates back to the end of the Civil War. According to the story, Confederate leaders sent a shipment of gold to Canada to fund their efforts to rebuild after the war.

However, along the way, the treasure disappeared, and some believe it was dumped into Lake Michigan near the shore.

The gold is said to have been hidden by Confederate operatives or sympathizers who were trying to avoid capture. It is rumored to consist of gold coins and bars worth millions of dollars.

The exact location of the treasure remains a mystery, but many speculate it could be near Frankfort or the Manitou Islands.

The story is tied to the Confederacy’s desperate attempts to move resources out of the United States after their defeat. Historical records do not confirm the shipment, but the legend has persisted for generations.

The treasure is believed to have been hidden in the late 1860s, as the Confederacy’s remnants scattered. Whether it was intentionally dumped or lost in an accident, the gold’s fate has fascinated those who search for lost riches.

How much the treasure would be worth today

If the Confederate gold were recovered, experts estimate the gold alone would be worth around $20 million.

The Lost Silver Mine of Ontonagon – $20,000,000+

The Lost Silver Mine of Ontonagon is one of Michigan’s most intriguing treasure legends. In the early 1800s, a group of French explorers discovered a rich silver deposit along the Ontonagon River.

The mine was said to have produced a significant amount of silver, but it was mysteriously abandoned and hidden after a series of unfortunate events.

The treasure is believed to consist of large amounts of silver, including silver bars and coins. The explorers who discovered it are thought to have hidden the silver to protect it from rival miners and local tribes.

The mine’s location remains unknown, but it is widely believed to be in the dense forests around Ontonagon in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.

The discovery of the silver is often attributed to the French, who were active in the region during the early 1800s. The silver is believed to have been hidden in the early 1800s, likely around 1820.

How much the treasure would be worth today

Based on the estimated amount of silver believed to be hidden, it could be worth anywhere from $10 million to $20 million.

The Ghost Town Treasure of Fayette – $8,000,000+

The Ghost Town Treasure of Fayette is one of Michigan’s most mysterious and elusive treasures. Fayette was once a bustling iron smelting town in the late 1800s, but it was abandoned after the ironworks closed.

Legends say that before the town was deserted, a fortune in gold, silver, and cash was hidden by the workers or the town’s owners to protect it from thieves or financial ruin.

The treasure is believed to consist of gold coins, silver bars, and valuable documents. Some locals claim that the treasure was buried in the nearby forests or hidden within the ruins of the old town itself.

The people believed to have hidden the treasure include former workers and investors who were determined to safeguard their assets. After the ironworks ceased operations, the town was left to decay, and the treasure was said to be lost with it.

The treasure is believed to have been hidden in the late 1800s, possibly around 1890, when the town was abandoned.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The gold and silver alone could be valued at $5 million to $8 million.

The Lost Train Gold of Grayling – $10,000,000+

The Lost Train Gold of Grayling is another one of Michigan’s most intriguing treasure tales. During the Civil War, a train carrying gold intended for the Union army was said to have been derailed near Grayling.

The treasure is rumored to consist of gold coins, bars, and other valuable items, which were meant to support the Union war effort. The crew, fearing the Confederate forces would capture the train, decided to bury the treasure somewhere near the town.

The gold is believed to have been hidden by Union soldiers or railway workers, possibly with the help of local civilians. According to some accounts, the treasure was buried near a bend in the Au Sable River, just outside of Grayling.

The treasure is believed to have been hidden in the early 1860s, during the Civil War.

How much the treasure would be worth today

Experts estimate the value of the gold could be as high as $10 million.

The Shipwreck Treasure of Whitefish Point – $30,000,000+

The Shipwreck Treasure of Whitefish Point is one of Michigan’s most famous and mysterious maritime legends. Whitefish Point, located on the shores of Lake Superior, is known for its rough waters and dangerous conditions.

Over the years, many ships have sunk in this area, including the infamous shipwreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald in 1975. Some believe that valuable treasure from these ships remains hidden beneath the waves near Whitefish Point.

The treasure is believed to consist of gold, silver, and other precious goods that were lost in shipwrecks over the years. The most well-known of these treasures is from a shipwreck dating back to the early 1800s, but some believe the loot includes items from even later wrecks.

These treasures were thought to have been aboard ships like the Augusta, James B. Colgate, and the Northwest, which sank in the dangerous waters of the Great Lakes.

Many believe the treasure was lost due to the treacherous conditions of Lake Superior, with many of the ships sinking during storms or while navigating the sharp reefs around Whitefish Point.

The treasure is believed to have been lost between the 1800s and early 1900s, with shipwrecks happening throughout this period.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The gold, silver, and artifacts could be worth around $20 million to $30 million.

The Tecumseh Cache – $10,000,000+

The Tecumseh Cache is a legendary treasure hidden in Michigan that dates back to the War of 1812. The treasure is believed to have been buried by the famous Native American leader, Tecumseh, who led his people in the fight against American forces during the war.

After his death in 1813, rumors spread that he had hidden a large cache of valuables before his final battle.

The cache is thought to contain weapons, gold, silver, and other valuables that were important to Tecumseh and his warriors.

The exact location of the treasure is unclear, but it is believed to be somewhere in southern Michigan, possibly near the town of Battle Creek. Some theories suggest it may be buried near the sites of significant battles, where Tecumseh’s forces were defeated.

How much the treasure would be worth today

Estimates suggest the treasure could be valued between $5 million and $10 million, depending on the condition and rarity of the artifacts.

The Lost Treasure of Beaver Island’s Mormon King – $10,000,000+

In the mid-1800s, Beaver Island in Michigan became the center of a religious community led by a man named James Strang, often called the “Mormon King.”

Strang claimed to be a prophet and established his own kingdom on the island after breaking away from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. As the self-proclaimed king, Strang amassed a fortune, including gold, silver, and valuables, which he allegedly hid before his downfall.

The treasure is believed to consist of gold coins, silver bars, and religious artifacts, with Strang possibly hiding it to protect his wealth after tensions with the U.S. government and the local community escalated.

Strang’s kingdom ended abruptly in 1856 when he was assassinated, and the treasure was never recovered. Some theories suggest that Strang’s followers hid the loot in various locations on Beaver Island to keep it hidden from authorities.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The Lost Treasure of Beaver Island could be worth between $5 million to $10 million.

The Treasure of Sleeping Bear Dunes – $5,000,000+

The legend of the Sleeping Bear Dunes treasure dates back to the early 1800s when a group of French traders is said to have hidden their fortune in gold and silver near the dunes.

The traders, who had been traveling through the area, feared an attack from Native American tribes or other hostile forces. To protect their riches, they supposedly buried the treasure near the iconic dunes of Lake Michigan.

The treasure is believed to consist of gold coins, silver bars, and precious items collected during their trading ventures. The exact location of the hidden loot is still unknown, though some think it may be buried deep in the sand dunes or hidden in nearby caves.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The treasure of Sleeping Bear Dunes could be worth between $3 million and $5 million.

The Thunder Bay Shipwrecks – $15,000,000+

Thunder Bay has earned its name due to the many shipwrecks that have occurred in the area. During the 19th and early 20th centuries, ships carrying valuable cargo such as gold, silver, and trade goods sank in the bay due to storms or navigational errors.

The most notable shipwrecks in Thunder Bay include the “Cornelia B. Windiate” and the “William P. Scripps,” both believed to have been carrying treasures that could still be hidden beneath the water.

The cargo believed to be hidden in these shipwrecks includes gold coins, silver bullion, and luxury goods intended for trade. The ships were often wrecked during fierce storms while navigating the dangerous waters of the bay.

Some believe that the treasure from the wrecks is scattered throughout the bay, lying at the bottom of the cold waters. Thunder Bay has become a popular destination for wreck divers and explorers hoping to uncover the riches that remain hidden for more than a century.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The treasure from the Thunder Bay shipwrecks could be worth an estimated $10 million to $15 million.

The Civil War Gold Near Jackson – $10,000,000+

The story of the Civil War gold near Jackson, Michigan, dates back to the final days of the Civil War in 1865. It is believed that a shipment of gold was being transported to Washington D.C. to help fund the Union Army.

The treasure is thought to be hidden in the forests and hills around Jackson, Michigan. Some believe that the gold was buried by Union soldiers or a group of Confederate spies who were aware of the shipment.

Several theories exist about the exact location of the gold, with some suggesting that it was hidden near the Grand River or in other nearby locations.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The Civil War gold near Jackson could be worth an estimated $5 million to $10 million.

The Lost Smuggler’s Silver in Detroit – $2,000,000+

The Lost Smuggler’s Silver in Detroit has its roots in the 1800s, during a time when smuggling was common along the Great Lakes. It is believed that a smuggler, known only as “Captain Edward,” was transporting a large shipment of silver from Canada to the United States. Captain Edward allegedly buried the treasure near the Detroit River to hide it from authorities.

The silver is thought to be hidden somewhere in or around Detroit, possibly near the riverfront or along the edges of the city’s early settlement areas. Despite many attempts, no one has been able to locate the treasure.

The treasure was likely buried around the 1820s, though the exact year remains uncertain. As the story goes, Captain Edward either died or was captured, and the treasure was lost to history.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The Lost Smuggler’s Silver could be worth an estimated $1 million to $2 million or even more.

The Mystery of Poverty Island – $10,000,000+

The Mystery of Poverty Island revolves around a rumored treasure buried on the island in Lake Michigan. The treasure is said to consist of gold and silver coins, hidden by a group of pirates or even British soldiers.

The story traces back to the early 1800s when the island was believed to be a hiding place for those trying to conceal valuable goods.

The treasure is believed to have been buried by either the notorious pirate Black Bartholomew or by British soldiers during the War of 1812. The island’s remote location made it an ideal spot for concealing loot.

Poverty Island is located off the coast of Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, in Lake Michigan. The treasure is believed to be hidden beneath the island’s surface or perhaps submerged underwater near its shores. The treasure is thought to have been buried in the early 19th century.

How much the treasure would be worth today

The gold and silver coins hidden on the island could have a value of approximately $10 million, depending on their condition and rarity.

The Sunken Treasure of Saginaw Bay – $5,000,000+

The Sunken Treasure of Saginaw Bay is a legendary treasure believed to have been lost in the 19th century. The treasure is said to be a cargo of gold and silver, hidden on a ship that sank in the bay. The ship was believed to be carrying valuable goods when it went down in a storm around the 1850s.

It is believed that the treasure was aboard a ship called the “Michigan,” which sank after encountering rough weather on Lake Huron near Saginaw Bay. Some theories suggest that the ship was carrying goods for wealthy investors or merchants.

The treasure is thought to be hidden beneath the waters of Saginaw Bay, specifically in the area known for frequent shipwrecks. The exact location of the shipwreck is unclear, and treasure hunters have been searching for it for over a century. The treasure is believed to have been lost sometime in the mid-1800s.

How much the treasure would be worth today

If recovered, the sunken treasure of Saginaw Bay could be worth around $5 million today.

About Keith Jackson - Geologist

Keith Jackson is an avid rockhound who is constantly exploring new sites to expand his collection. He is an active Geologist with a wealth of experience and information from across the country that he loves to share with the Rock Chasing crew.

Leave a Comment